- #1
Dee
Based on the theory that language is determined by thought, I was wondering if it is possible for a person to have absolutely no thoughts (while retaining consciousness) and be able to speak.
Dee
Dee
Dee said:I understand the non-audiable form of language, eg sign language and writing. But since our forms of human language are not instinctive (as in the case of bees maybe)
then surly the must be some sort of internal processing of the raw symbols (ie letters) into meaningful comprehension? For example, young children can be taught new words but they will not understand them until they have mastered certain intellectual skills during the process of cognitive growth.
ryan_m_b said:Lastly think of this; whilst children may not have comprehension of the meaning of most words how would you tell if one never established comprehension? How would you tell if an adult had lived their whole lives not understanding anything that was going on around them. When somebody talks to them they respond in a manner that they know has worked before, I.e. I say to this person "Hello, nice to meet you" and they respond to those sounds and gestures by saying "nice to meet you too" and shaking my hand however they have no comprehension of what is going on, they are merely choosing an appropriate response from a list they have established.
This is a highly debated question in the field of linguistics. Some argue that thoughts and language are interconnected and that thoughts are necessary for language to exist. Others argue that language can exist without thoughts and that thoughts are not a prerequisite for language.
There is no conclusive evidence that thoughts are necessary for language. However, studies have shown that individuals who have difficulty with language also struggle with organizing and expressing their thoughts. This suggests a strong link between thoughts and language.
Again, this is a matter of debate. Some argue that language is purely a social construct and does not require thoughts for its existence. Others argue that even if language can exist without thoughts, it would be limited and not as complex as language that is connected to thoughts.
Thoughts play a crucial role in language as they provide the content and meaning behind our words. Our thoughts shape the way we use language and communicate with others. Without thoughts, language would lack depth and nuance.
Yes, there have been many studies exploring the connection between thoughts and language. Some studies have shown that individuals who have a well-developed understanding of language also have a more sophisticated thought process. Other studies have looked at how language is used to express thoughts and emotions. Overall, the research suggests a strong link between thoughts and language.