Why does every cable have 2 different tensions?

  • Thread starter Scintillation
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Cable
In summary, the concept of non-massless cables was introduced, which is different from the usual problems where the cable is assumed to be massless. There are three instances where the tension on both ends of the cable is the same, and this is only true if the cable is massless, there is no acceleration, or the cable is in free-fall. However, a cable with mass does not have equal tension throughout its length, and the tension varies with location. This is due to the cable's weight and its equilibrium position, which is a parabolic curve when the sag is less than a few percent of the horizontal span.
  • #1
Scintillation
27
0

Homework Statement


I was recently introduced to the concept of non-massless cables. I am used to solving problems where the cable is massless, and therefore tension on both ends of the cable are the same.

However, my TA mentioned that this is only true in 3 instances.
1. If the cable is massless.
2. If there is no acceleration on the cables (that is Fnet=0)
3. (Actually a special case of 2) When the cable is in free-fall.

The reason for this is never explained however. When I was doing a problem, with a cable in between two blocks, I initially tried to make tensions on both ends of the cable to be the same. Yet, I was told this was incorrect, because the cable has mass.

Can someone clarify the reason why cables always have two different tensions, even massless ones (where t1=t2)?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
A cable with mass doesn't just have two different tensions. The tension in the cable varies with location along the entire cable, in order for each small section of the cable to be accelerated. Draw a free body diagram on a small section of cable and use Newton's second law to predict how the tension changes with position if the mass per unit length of the cable is ρ.
 
  • #3
If a cable with mass is strung 'horizontally' between 2 blocks spaced a distance L apart, it assumes an equilibrium position in the shape of the catenary curve, which is very closely approximated by a parabolic curve when the sag is less than the a few percent of the horizontal span, where the amount of sag depends upon the total length of the cable between the blocks. Tension forces in cables always act along the length of the cable, and vary along its length. At the low point of the curve, where the tangent to the curve is horizontal, the tension force in the cable must be horizontal, and this is known as the horizontal tension in the cable. From equilibrium considerations in the horizontal direction, the horizontal tension is the same at any point in the curve, but there will also be a vertical component of the tension due to the cable's weight. This implies that at any point in the curve away from the low point, the tension in the cable is greater than the tension at the low point, becoming a maximum at the support where the angle that the tangent of the curve makes with the horizontal is greatest (and a minimum at the low point).
I think you may have not understood the TA's explanation, or maybe he or she stated it incorrectly. A cable with mass does not have equal tension in it throughout its length, even if it is at rest, whether strung vertically or horizontally. You might want to clarify what you mean by a 'cable between 2 blocks'.
 

Related to Why does every cable have 2 different tensions?

1. Why do cables have 2 different tensions?

Cables have 2 different tensions because of the need to balance the forces acting on the cable. The first tension, known as the "working tension", is the force required to maintain the cable in its intended position. The second tension, known as the "breaking tension", is the maximum force that the cable can withstand before breaking. By having 2 different tensions, cables are able to safely bear the load while also having a margin of safety.

2. Can a cable have more than 2 tensions?

Technically, yes, a cable can have more than 2 tensions. However, in most cases, 2 tensions are sufficient for the intended purpose of the cable. In some specialized applications, such as suspension bridges, cables may have multiple tensions in order to distribute the weight more evenly and increase stability.

3. How are the tensions of a cable determined?

The tensions of a cable are determined through various factors, including the weight of the object being supported, the distance between anchor points, and the properties of the cable itself (such as its material and diameter). Engineers use mathematical equations and calculations to determine the appropriate tensions for a specific cable based on these factors.

4. Can the tensions of a cable change over time?

Yes, the tensions of a cable can change over time due to various factors. For example, if the weight of the object being supported changes, the tensions may need to be adjusted. Additionally, environmental factors such as temperature and weather conditions can affect the tensions of a cable. Regular maintenance and adjustments may be necessary to ensure the cable remains at the appropriate tensions.

5. Are there any risks associated with imbalanced cable tensions?

Yes, imbalanced cable tensions can pose risks to the stability and safety of the cable. If one tension is significantly higher than the other, it can cause the cable to become overstretched and potentially break. This can lead to disastrous consequences, especially in critical structures such as bridges and elevators. It is important for engineers to carefully calculate and monitor the tensions of cables to prevent imbalances and potential risks.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
19
Views
847
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
484
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
10
Views
4K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
996
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
6K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
11
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
17
Views
1K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
1
Views
806
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
1K
Back
Top