Meteorite Heating: Friction or Compression?

  • Thread starter CatWoman
  • Start date
In summary, there is a misconception that the heating effect of a meteorite entering the atmosphere is primarily due to friction. However, it is actually caused by the rapid compression of air molecules as the meteorite travels at high speeds. Some argue that this is just a matter of semantics, as both friction and compression play a role in the heating process. Ultimately, the meteorite will be surrounded by superheated plasma, regardless of the specific mechanisms involved.
  • #1
CatWoman
30
0
Most people say it is due to friction with the atmosphere, however I have read that this is a misconception and that the majority of the heating effect comes from the rapid compression of the air infront of the meteorite as it travels at very high speeds. Which is the right answer please. (from a trainee Physics teacher)
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
  • #2
It's from a claim that it's only friction if the air flows around something (air resistance/drag is a fluid dynamics phenomena) while at the speed of a meteor it's simply momentum transfer of it hitting air molecules and accelerating them to mach 30 (or whatever the meteor is doing)

Personally I think it's just pedantry/hair-splitting
 
  • #3
There is probably some element of the plasma produced at the front of the meteor super-heating material, but that's because of friction so... yeah, what mgb_phys said in his last sentence. Maybe the compression in the front and around the "nose" of the meteor can produce shocks that break a meteor, but that's not the same as heating.

In the end, the falling object is going to be enveloped in superheated plasma, so however the fluid dynamics play out, there is going to be heating even on the "tail" of the meteor.
 

Related to Meteorite Heating: Friction or Compression?

1. Why do meteorites burn up when they enter Earth's atmosphere?

Meteorites burn up when they enter Earth's atmosphere due to friction with the air molecules. As they travel through the atmosphere at high speeds, they encounter a lot of resistance which generates heat. This heat causes the meteorite to vaporize and disintegrate, creating the bright streaks we see in the sky.

2. How do meteorites survive the intense heat of entering Earth's atmosphere?

Meteorites are able to survive the intense heat of entering Earth's atmosphere due to their high melting points and strong structures. Most meteorites are made of iron, nickel, and other metals which have high melting points. Additionally, the outer layers of meteorites often melt and vaporize, acting as a protective shield for the inner layers.

3. Do all meteorites burn up when they enter Earth's atmosphere?

No, not all meteorites burn up when they enter Earth's atmosphere. Some larger or more dense meteorites are able to withstand the heat and make it to the ground. These meteorites are often found in the form of meteorite craters or impact sites.

4. Can meteorites cause harm or damage when they burn up in the atmosphere?

In most cases, meteorites burning up in the atmosphere do not cause harm or damage to people or objects on the ground. The heat generated is dissipated over a large area and the remaining fragments are often small and light enough to not cause significant damage. However, there have been rare instances where larger meteorites have caused damage upon impact.

5. How do scientists study meteorites that have burned up in the atmosphere?

Scientists study meteorites that have burned up in the atmosphere by collecting the fragments that have landed on the ground. These fragments can provide valuable information about the composition and origins of the meteorite. Additionally, scientists can study the light emitted during the burning process to gather information about the meteorite's speed, trajectory, and chemical composition.

Similar threads

  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
1
Views
371
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
1
Views
877
  • Thermodynamics
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
18
Views
323
  • Materials and Chemical Engineering
Replies
12
Views
4K
Replies
15
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • Astronomy and Astrophysics
Replies
6
Views
3K
Back
Top